end one: Frog-kissing
To find a Prince, some frog-kissing is probably involved.
So it is with whisky – remember the sheep-poo germinated Floki from Iceland?. A dram that was definitely over-frogged.
A few years back I bought a bottle of Manuka Honey Whisky, made by a self-described Organic Distillery north of Auckland. I am not going to review the whisky it here, other than to say it was horrible and I’m trying to forget I ever tasted it. The best thing I can say is that all but two tasting-sized drams of the bottle’s contents became a fairly dire ingredient in a chocolate birthday cake.
Sometimes you only know a mistake when you make it a second time – let me introduce you to:
Batch 10 Manuka Smoked Kentucky Whisky (sic)
ABV: 45%.
Eye: Nice amber gold colour
Nose: sweet smoke, with an strange vegetal note in the background (like a kawakawa plant-based ointment). A bucolic, rural note of horse droppings and straw.
Palate: Strongly vegetal, sweet with heavy smoke. Harsh and scrape-y on the tongue. Honey at the back of throat goes quickly, then returns in the finish.
Finish: Sour, in a bad way – like poorly-dried laundry.
Comment: Reminiscent of Floki, with a large dollop of honey added. And that Floki-ish after-taste continues way too long.
Batch 10 is another north Auckland distillery. Their website waxes lyrical about this product, as I would expect it to.
Manuka Smoked Whisky
Premium Kentucky whisky, smoked with Manuka. Made in small batchs (sic) with our secret Manuka smoking process.
It has a strong smoked single malt Whisky front followed by a smooth finish. Something quite special and tricky to make.
Comment
Over the years, I have avoided making adverse comment in this blog; not casting doubt on others’ products – especially when I can’t do it better myself. I prefer to show you my notes and let you make your own judgements.
However, once very so often, something comes up that I don’t feel I can let pass without remark.
I have a few problems with the information provided on Batch 10 and how it has been constructed.
The main rules of making Kentucky Whiskey are:
- In Kentucky, whisky is spelt with an e.
- Kentucky Whiskey is made in the US from a mash of 51% corn, aged in new charred oak barrels, and bottled at a minimum of 80 proof (40% alcohol by volume).
Bearing those in mind, I think that it is odd to described the Batch 10 product as a “premium Kentucky whisky” with a “single malt whisky front”.
Corn and malt are not the same. While corn can be used to make a type of malt (corn malt), malt generally refers to germinated and dried barley – a different grain.
I am also puzzled by the inferred construction of the drink.
How can it be claimed to be “smoked with Manuka”? Did someone take manuka to Kentucky to use in the germination process?
Another quote from the Batch 10 website does not make anything clearer: “Infusing began in earnest … in the backwoods of Puhoi.” If the drink was made originally in Kentucky, does “infusing” hint that something has been added to it after it arrived in NZ?
I’d love an explanation, and there may be a perfectly good one.
I’m looking forward to hearing it.
The counterpoint of taste melodies go on forever! And what glorious tube artwork!
And At The Other End
On a far happier note, after Dramfest 2025, Whisky Galore’s website mentioned a Dramfest 2025 Exclusive Pokeno ‘Solera La Ina Hogshead no. 121’ from Auckland’s Pokeno Whisky, available ex-store.

Whisky Galore notes
“…The journey for this whisky began in 1923 when Hogshead No. 121 was manufactured at La Ina in Spain, then used to make fino sherry. The cask then made its way to Scotland, and was used to mature Scotch whisky for 30 years. In the 1950s, the cask, full of bulk whisky for blending, was sent to New Zealand, ending up in the Whisky Galore shop 50 years later as a display piece.
in 2023, Hogshead No. 121 was sent from Christchurch to Pokeno, where it was re-coopered and re-seasoned before being filled with mature Pokeno whisky that had previously matured in an a fresh PX sherry cask. The last influence on this dram was cask No. 121, with a final 6 months of maturation.”
My tasting notes:
Pokeno Solera La Ina Hogshead No. 121
ABV: 52.1%
Colour: Rich gold, edging dark.
Nose: Very attractive. Light sacking, nutty chocolate & golden syrup with oak sawdust. A light vanilla note. Very slight nose prickle (the cask-strength alcohol is well integrated and not in-your-face). Brown sugar and sherry.
Palate: Sweet and “kicky”. Hot tongue. Nice tannic note, drying my tongue. Beautifully integrated counterpoint of flavours, with sweet and sour simultaneously holding sway.
Finish: Everything stays and mixes.
Comment: Superb!! The contrasting melodies of taste go on forever! And, in true Pokeno style, what glorious tube artwork!
And here is your Prince!
Slainte
John
