Observations on Whisky Matters – Change for the Better?

A Three percent Drop

by Pat

No, not a gift mortgage rate.  That’s definitely not the case!

I am referring to the amount of Alcohol by Volume (ABV) in your whisky.

Recently I was trying to drink some of my surplus whisky from my collection, having finally decided what I really want to keep and pass on.

I chanced to come across a couple of old bottles of Grants 12 year old blended whisky.  It’s a whisky I really like when I just want something non-challenging before dinner.

To my surprise (and horror), when I looked at the two bottles, one was 43% abv and the other was 40%.  Both were normal bottlings, the only difference being that one was newer.

Vertical comparison

The next move?

Simple!

Open both to do a vertical tasting to compare the two expressions.  What a difference three percent makes!  The higher abv version tasted like a single malt, the lower (40% one) just didn’t!

This got me thinking.

I checked out my wife’s favourite Jim Beam Black and, sure enough, what used to be 43% is also now a 40%!

Now, I don’t really know what is driving these drops in ‘horsepower’.  Is it an attempt to lower the tax on the beverage?  Or are distillers and blenders trying to stretch the stock further to cover increased demand?  To my mind, the Black from Beam and the 12 year old from Grants were both traditionally meant to be that next step up from entry level.  They were intended to offer a more refined experience – but has lowering the abv achieved that goal?

Looking back through my collection of whisky miniatures – which doubles as an excellent archive – I see that even the Glenfiddich entry level 12yo (now sold at 40%) used to be 43 percent.

When you cheapen your products for market demand, your reputation suffers.  We have pointed this out in previous articles, particularly in relation to some well-known brands’ supplied to supermarkets in the UK.

After having had vertical tastings from previous years from these distilleries it becomes clear that quality has gone on the line as a result.

Does a 3 percent abv drop make a difference?

Oh, yes, it does.

 

What Regulations? 

by John

It’s a bit like wearing knitted swimming togs or a mankini. You know it’s possible but, really, should you?

Since the early 14th century, Aqua Vitae (the water of life, and the fore-runner of whisky) has been stored – and matured – in oak barrels .  And people have got good at it over the years.  Distil a liquid mixture of barley, yeast and water to produce alcohol, put the result in a barrel and go away for a few years until you think it might taste good.

It’s an extremely simplistic view, but that’s the bones of how whisky is made.

A recent magazine article on NZ’s TV focussed me on the concept of NZ-made, rapid-matured, whisky and rum.

An operation called Eltom Distillery, in Auckland’s Parnell, is looking to revolutionise the way whisky (in particular) is “aged”.

In researching what Eltom was all about, I came across a very informative Stuff article, which made things a little less murky.  The article is well worth reading if you’re a whisky fan.  I found the bit about how the “products had come out on top (in the company’s) own taste testings against well-established, well-known traditional spirits” particularly interesting!

The “process”

I am at a bit of a loss as to how to describe the rapid-maturing process, but start with a pressure cooker and go from there.

As I understand the concept, cubes of various oak are added to an un-aged spirit.  The “various oak” bit determines what planned spirit-type outcome is expected.  The liquid (with the cubes in it) is then heated and pressurised – a process which reportedly results is a matured flavour profile.

It has been claimed that the process can produce the equivalent of 20-year-old matured spirit in just a few days.

I have some issues.

Issue 1 – Ingredients:

The NZ Whisky guidelines from Distilled Spirits Aotearoa (DSA) state, in Clause 3, that “ingredients intended to flavour the whisky … are not allowed”.

The DSA Guidelines also say that “Wood chip may not be used or added to the cask during maturation”.  It strikes me that both of these points are being overlooked by the distillery.  I suppose that Eltoms could get around the last bit by saying there is no cask involved in the maturation.

That may be true, but it’s a bit of a stretch!

To the best of my knowledge, the Guidelines are currently just that – guidelines.  Sadly, they are not regulations, requirements, or legally enforceable –  although they damned-well should be!

Issue 2 – Independence of tasting:

Conducting taste testing of your own products against others, and then claiming yours came out top, seems to lack independence.  A lot.  Just me?

Issue 3 – Stock Levels:

I thought it would be fun to try some of Eltom’s output, just to see what it’s like.

So I went to their website to buy some.

The site currently has a range of eight products – one gin, two “single malt” whiskies, one American whiskey, a “Lost” whisky, and three rums.

All of them, bar one of the rums, are marked as “sold out”.

Question:  if, as Eltom claim, the products can be produced “in just a few days”, how come they have no stock?  Strange!

Sadly, though, the lack of purchase-able stock indicates that I may have to wait a while to give you the results of my (truly independent) tasting.  If ever.

In the meantime, I’d love to know how traditional whisky/whiskey drinkers and – possibly more importantly – the generations of distillers, view this new process.

I have a vision of them all, in their graves and spinning like rotisserie chickens!

 

PS:  In writing this article, I have not spoken to anyone from Eltom Distilleries about their processes or products.  After recent experiences with other “original” products, from the Puhoi area north of Auckland, I couldn’t really see the point.